DO NOT MISS OUR SANJAYA TRIBUTE SHOW

IDOL RADIO SHOW WILL PAY TRIBUTE TO THE GREAT SANJAYA ON MONDAY APRIL 23RD 10PM EASTERN/ 9 CENTRAL/ 7 PACIFIC TIME.   DO NOT MISS THIS SHOW!!

Next week on Idol Radio Show

Monday:     Sanjaya Tribute

Tuesday:     Recap of Performances

Wednesday:  Eliminations and Special Guest Trenyce From Idol Season 2

Thursday:     Special Guest Scott Savol From Idol Season 4

Sign up for our podcast so that you can get the show automatically downloaded into your itunes each episode.  ITS FREE!

SIGN UP FROM THE MAIN PAGE OF OUR SITE AT www.IdolRadioShow.com

We also added the TELL A FRIEND feature to our site so that you can enter all of your friends e mail addresses and let them know about Idol Radio Show.  Check it out from the main page of our site.

THIS WEEKS Idol Performance MP3'S ARE READY FOR DOWNLOAD

click here to download

This week on idol…

 Let me start by saying that country music falls very low on my list of favorite genres of music. There are a few artists and songs I know and like, but growing up on the Southside of Chicago did not expose me to much country music. That being said, I was really not expecting to enjoy the show much. To make matters worse there is no “country singer” in the cast, oops did I say “cast”? I meant to say there is no contestant who professes to be a country singer. The little I do know and appreciate about country music is that it is a form of music that is based upon good story telling. It doesn’t take a lot of finesse to be a country singer and matter of fact if you have too much finesse it doesn’t match. Imagine Celine Dion belting out a country tune or perhaps Beyonce putting her rapid singing style on a southern number. Follow me? So, with these things in mind and with our resident seven remaining I found myself actually wishing for an appearance from Carrie Underwood or maybe even Bucky Covington. I am not a fan of either of them, but at least they understand the genre.

 Normally when writing these observations, I try and go in the order of appearances. If you have been reading these you already know that I often have a hard time remembering what order they went in if I don’t have my notes. So rather than struggle and try and remember the order, this time I am just going to rank them from best to worst.

1. Melinda - Are you surprised? I know I am sounding like a broken record, but if there was ever a professional to hit the stage of Idol, Melinda is it. Alan, from The Official Soul Patrol has in his mind that Lakisha at her best would give Melinda a run for her money. Melinda would have to have the flu and be doped up on cold medicine for Lakisha to even enter into her realm, but more on Lakisha later. I think Alan might be under this impression due to the fact that Lakisha has one maybe two notes higher in vocal range than Melinda, but what Melinda might lack in vocal range she makes up other areas. You will never hear Melinda sing Jennifer Hudson or Mariah Carey type notes and she is fully aware of that which is why she is a professional. She has complete and utter knowledge and control over her instruments. Her interpretation skills are excellent and she knows how to pull the best out of every lyric. I had never heard the song she performed, and I can’t remember every line but while listening she pulled me into the story of this “feisty woman in jeans” and made me want to know more about “her”. What I admire most about Melinda is the investment she puts into every song.
2. Phil – Now you are surprised, because I am too. I kept looking at my list and I kept saying wait, Phil can’t be my second best performance of the night, but playing the night back in my head, he is. Phil has a tendency to have bad starts in his performances, but this night he had a great start and was consistent throughout the performance. I think what helped was the song was simple and for more than half of it he was merely singing along with the background, who by the way are awesome. At times Phil’s voice impresses me especially when he is in his upper range. If he would take control of his instrument he would be a very enjoyable singer.
3. Jordin – On the right song this young lady is very impressive. Her best performance for me this season was “I Who Have Nothing”. She was tender and used more phrasing than high notes. No denying she has a powerful instrument, but it takes more than just long high notes to make a song interesting. Her “Broken Wings” came across to me as one long note and that got louder. I was not invested in the song at all.
4. Lakisha – I am not a “I told you so” type of person, but …..  What can I say? Lakisha made a big mistake in thinking she could take on a song that is super popular by an Idol winner. I don’t understand why she keeps picking these songs that have already either been performed on the show or done by past contestants outside the show. What is she really saying? Not only is she setting herself up to be compared to the original, but also the former contestants and she keeps losing. If she had the capabilities of Melinda, given her gospel background she should have been able to take “Jesus, Take The Wheeel” and turned it into a stirring gospel plea. The formula would have been simple. Slow the verses down almost to no tempo at all and build into the chorus with all the gospel flair she could muster. Instead she turned in a performance that was forgettable and in spots had you praying for “Jesus, forget the wheel, take over this song.”
5. Chris – I have a confession. The first time I heard Chris, I thought ok he is really something new to Idol. They have finally chosen a contestant that I could actually see competing in the real world. He has the “boy band” looks and appeal and is a decent substitute when you can’t get Justin Timberlake. Now I am annoyed. I don’t know if this is truly his voice or if he is really doing his best JT impersonation every week. Maybe he has convinced himself that this is truly his voice, if so he might as well give it up now. Justin has the “JT” brand on lock and is not letting go anytime soon.
6. Blake – A favorite of many, but never a one of mine and the cracks in his armor are showing. I think I said it a few weeks back that Blake would make a great producer. I still believe that. His performance tonight was in desperate need of his producer touch but he decided to just sing it. There was nothing I enjoyed about this performance. I could not wait for it to end.
7. Sanjaya – Why? Just why? He made the same mistake Lakisha made. Truly I am not the only one that remembers the fantastic job Fantasia did on this song in season three. This was hard to watch and listen too. After such a great job last week, it made it even harder to understand. The kid actually does have potential, but everything about this performance was wrong. The standing next to Kenya Hathaway(the background singer) only made me desire her to grab the mic from his hand and finish the song. His walking around gave me the impression that it is hard for him to walk and sing at the same time. This might be accurate for his best performance to date happened when he was sitting. That’s the key. Don’t MOVE!

 So there is my ranking. What makes this bizarre is that I ranked Phil number two and I think he will be the one sent home. I just think it’s too late for him to win over any new fans and being in the bottom three the past few weeks it just makes statistical sense that his number is up. Joining him once again will be Chris and I think time is now running out for Lakisha and she will make her debut in the bottom three.

 The Results

 We were treated to two performances. One by Martina McBride and they brought back Gwen Stefani to sing again. Oh that wasn’t Gwen? Awkward, Fergie performed.

 I knew they were going to do their standard split the group thing but I just didn’t know who they were going to chose as the “goat”. I was thinking they would choose Sanjaya since they seem to get such joy tormenting him. Melinda was actually picked to choose between the top and bottom three, being the diplomat she is, she decided to sit in the middle. I love Melinda. So they pushed her over to Phil, Chris and Jordin who were the top three. Phil and Chris I was really surprised. This is really a strange season.

 That left Sanjaya, Lakisha and Blake as the bottom three and Blake was spared first. The crowd was very pleased. Not a big fan of Blake’s but I was sort of surprised he was in the bottom. He really did a poor job the night before, but I thought his fan base would spare him. This is a wake up call for him that he is not as safe as he thought he was.

 So, that left Sanjaya and Lakisha as the bottom two and a massive smile on Simon’s face, which opens the door for several conspiracy theories due to the fact the Simon basically, told the world that they were tired of Sanjaya and this was no longer “funny”.

Sanjaya was sent home in the midst of tears and I actually felt a little sad. I know I ranked him last and he has a lot of improvement to do but the kid was entertaining and I had grown somewhat attached to him. Oddly, I don’t think the departure of Lakisha would have been that upsetting. She has been slipping every week and it is starting to show that she is not as talented as folks are making her out to be.

 I confessed on the show that if I wasn’t writing these weekly observations, my watching the show would end here. I would simply pick up the audio and video performances from Melinda and maybe Jordin (if she had a good night) each week. But I shall keep an open mind and maybe now that the other contestants are not threatened by Sanjaya they will step up to the plate and start delivering some awesome performances. When I dream I dream in color.

 Kudos to Sanjaya for his farewell song and the switch in lyrics. “Let’s give them something to talk about other than hair…”

 So, what will we have to talk about now that he is gone?

Show Archives